Here for YOU Today and There for your FAMILY Tomorrow

What Happens When the Executor and Heirs Disagree? Not my Family…


Executor and Heirs Disagree

Here’s an example of what happens when things don’t go as planned in estate planning. A parent dies, and has left everything to his two children, with a best friend designated as the executor (like the guy in this picture). The will stipulates that the executor is only to be paid fees for incurred charges. But then the executor decides that he deserves more, and cuts himself a check from the estate for $15,000. What, if anything, can the heirs do? recently posted an article, “Fight brewing over 'best friend's' executor fee.” As the article explains, the state statute stipulates that 6% commissions may be taken on all income received by an executor, like interest and dividends. In addition, the executor may take commissions on all "corpus,” which is all the assets controlled by the executor that’s equal to 5% on the first $200,000, 3.5% on the excess over $200,000 up to $1 million, and 2% over $1 million.

The executor and the decedent can agree on additional or lesser amounts. The judge can also increase commissions upon application by the executor or decrease the commissions upon application by a beneficiary. Another possibility is that the executor signed a fee agreement where he waived the fee. In that instance, the agreement may be binding against the executor and enforceable by the beneficiaries of the estate. However, the beneficiaries would have to pursue that claim on their own with their own attorney.

An attorney who’s representing the executor would have a conflict of interest representing the executor in his capacity as executor of the estate and the beneficiaries in their claim against the executor.

What if a beneficiary believes that the executor had no right to commissions, either based on a contract the executor signed with the testator or because the services the executor rendered were "materially deficient" or that the actual pain, trouble and risk in settling the estate were substantially less than generally required for an estate of a similar size? In that case, you can ask the judge to reduce or eliminate the commissions.

Unfortunately, there is no cut-and-dried answer to this dilemma. If it comes to requiring litigation, the court will ultimately decide on the testator’s intent but it may not be as clear as the beneficiary thinks it is. The executor may end up being allowed to pay attorney’s fees with funds from the estate, which then takes a bite out of the estate that will eventually go to the beneficiaries. At the same time, sometimes circumstances or the law itself changes, and the court may enforce the intent of the testator, even if it’s different than what was written in the will. Every case is different.

Do you live in Miami-Dade, Broward, or Palm Beach counties in Florida? Laws are constantly changing-- has your estate plan been reviewed in the last 2-3 years? Call me (954-888-1747) right away for peace of mind. I can help!

  • My practice is exclusively estate planning and probate,
  • I have prepared numerous estate plans in 16 years of practice,
  • I have administered estates and trusts through Probate all over Florida,
  • I am a Certified Financial Planner Professional™, and
  • I am here for YOU today and there for your FAMILY tomorrow.

Reference: (April 17, 2017) “Fight brewing over 'best friend's' executor fee”

Why would we recommend D.T.F.? Several Reasons: Your ability to explain complex estate problems, clearly and patiently; your total lack of arrogance and pretense; a strong feeling that you are motivated by what you perceive is best for your client, rather than what would generate the largest legal fees; finally, and importantly, you are a lovely guy. A.C.

Two words cannot sum up the entire process of creating my “trust.” I enjoyed your attention to detail, your patience of explaining terms and conditions until I understood, also giving me copies to read and understand. Thank you for your suggestions on what was best for “me” but still allowing me to make my choice. Most of all, thank you for thinking of “me.” Wells Fargo said “you were the best” I cannot deny that. Again thank you very much for everything. Anna is an asset or a compliment to the firm. She is warm and very caring. It was great doing business. Thank you.